Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

Diminished Value by Vehicle

What buyers check on popular models after an accident, and how to claim the value you lost.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Quick Answer

If someone else hit your car, the at-fault driver’s insurer owes the repair and, in most states, its diminished value: the resale value it lost because it now has an accident on its history. How much a car loses depends on the model, its age and mileage, and what was damaged. Notes for popular models are below.

Every claim is different. This page is general, educational information, not legal advice. We’re vehicle appraisers, not a law firm, and we can’t represent you. Policies, laws and deadlines vary and change, so check your policy and talk with a licensed attorney in your state before relying on anything here.

Find Your Vehicle

How to Claim Diminished Value on Any Vehicle

  1. Keep the final repair invoice, photos of the damage, and any calibration or inspection reports.
  2. Get an independent appraisal based on sales of the same model with and without accident history.
  3. Send it to the at-fault insurer with a written demand. Don’t sign a release covering all property damage until diminished value is settled.
  4. If the offer is too low, use your state’s options: appraisal in North Carolina, property damage arbitration in South Carolina, or small claims court. What to do when the diminished value offer is too low

Estimate your car’s diminished value for free →

Notes by Model

Chevrolet Equinox

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean Equinoxes for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Airbags: whether any deployed.
  • Driver-assist sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Chevrolet Silverado

Silverados hold their value well, so the dollar loss from an accident can be large.

What buyers check

  • Frame and bed: anything structural, especially on trucks used for towing.
  • Trim and options: LT, LTZ, High Country and packages change value a lot.
  • 4x4 and suspension: front-end hits can affect alignment and suspension parts.
  • Paint and panels: large panel repairs show up on inspection and history reports.

Ford F-150

F-150s hold their value well, so the dollar loss from an accident can be large.

What buyers check

  • Aluminum body: F-150s from the 2015 model year on use an aluminum-alloy body, which needs a shop equipped for aluminum repair.
  • Frame and bed: anything structural, especially on trucks used for towing.
  • Trim and options: Lariat, Platinum and other trims and packages change value a lot.
  • 4x4 and suspension: front-end hits can affect alignment and suspension parts.

Honda Accord

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean Accords for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Airbags: whether any deployed.
  • Driver-assist sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Honda Civic

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean Civics for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Airbags: whether any deployed.
  • Driver-assist sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Honda CR-V

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean CR-Vs for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Hybrid models: whether the hybrid battery area was affected.
  • Driver-assist sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Hyundai Tucson

Here’s a real example from our appraisals.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean Tucsons for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Hybrid and plug-in models: whether the battery area was affected.
  • Driver-assist sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Example: 2019 Hyundai Tucson

One of our appraisals of a 2019 Hyundai Tucson:

  • Value before the accident: $21,216
  • Value after repair: $17,758
  • Appraised diminished value: $3,458 (16.3%)

This is an appraised value, not an amount recovered from an insurer. Every vehicle is different.

Jeep Wrangler

Wranglers hold their value well, so buyers pay a premium for clean history.

What buyers check

  • Frame: any frame repair is a major concern.
  • Off-road use: buyers check the underbody, axles and suspension.
  • Tops and doors: damage to removable tops, doors or the windshield frame.
  • Aftermarket parts: lifts, bumpers, winches and tires affect value and repair cost.

Nissan Altima

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean Altimas for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Airbags: whether any deployed.
  • Paint and panels: large repairs show up on inspection.

Ram 1500

Ram 1500s hold their value well, so the dollar loss from an accident can be large.

What buyers check

  • Frame and bed: anything structural, especially on trucks used for towing.
  • Air suspension: on trucks equipped with it, buyers want to know it wasn’t damaged.
  • Trim and options: Laramie, Limited and other trims change value a lot.
  • Paint and panels: large panel repairs show up on inspection and history reports.

Tesla Model 3

EV buyers are often cautious about crash history, so the loss can be significant.

What buyers check

  • Battery and cooling: buyers worry about hidden damage to the battery pack, even when the crash was elsewhere.
  • Repair shop: whether the car was fixed at a Tesla-approved body shop.
  • Cameras and sensors: proof that driver-assist cameras were calibrated after the repair.
  • Structure: any repairs to structural or aluminum parts.

Tesla Model Y

EV buyers are often cautious about crash history, so the loss can be significant.

What buyers check

  • Battery and cooling: buyers worry about hidden damage to the battery pack, even when the crash was elsewhere.
  • Large cast parts: the Model Y uses large one-piece castings, so damage near them raises repair questions.
  • Repair shop: whether the car was fixed at a Tesla-approved body shop.
  • Cameras and sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Toyota Camry

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean Camrys for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Airbags: whether any deployed.
  • Hybrid models: whether the hybrid battery area was affected.

Toyota RAV4

It’s one of the most common vehicles on the road, so used buyers have plenty of clean-history choices and often skip or pay less for one with an accident.

What buyers check

  • Accident history report: buyers compare it against the many clean RAV4s for sale.
  • Structural repairs: anything beyond bolt-on panels.
  • Hybrid and plug-in models: whether the battery area was affected.
  • Driver-assist sensors: proof of calibration after the repair.

Toyota Tacoma

Tacomas are known for strong resale value, so buyers pay a premium for clean history.

What buyers check

  • Frame: any frame repair is a major concern for buyers.
  • Off-road use: TRD and off-road trims get extra scrutiny of the underbody and suspension.
  • Bed and hitch: damage near the bed or tow hitch.
  • Aftermarket parts: lifts, bumpers and racks affect value and repair cost.

By Vehicle Type and Damage

Electric vehicles · Trucks · Luxury cars · Frame damage · Airbag deployment · Rear-end collisions

How We Help

We appraise your vehicle independently and online, from photos, and give you a report you can send to the insurer, use in an appraisal clause, or bring to court. Call or text 910-333-6001 to get started.

Diminished value claims aren’t offered in Nebraska or Michigan.

In the Carolinas? See diminished value in North Carolina and in South Carolina.

Custom, classic or collector car? See classic and collector car appraisals.

Common Questions

Do some cars lose more value after an accident?

Yes. Newer cars, cars that hold their value well, and cars with structural, airbag or battery damage usually lose more.

Does my model need a special appraisal?

No, but the appraisal should compare sales of the same model with and without accident history.

Is my car too old for diminished value?

Generally, cars 10 years old or newer with under 100,000 miles and no prior accidents have the strongest claims.

Related Guides

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.