Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

Appraisal Clause Umpire Services

A neutral umpire when the two appraisers can’t agree on a vehicle’s value.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Overview

When the appraisers on an auto appraisal clause can’t agree, the policy calls for an umpire. We serve as a neutral umpire on total loss and vehicle value disputes for appraisers, insurers and policyholders.

Every claim is different. This page is general, educational information, not legal advice. We’re vehicle appraisers, not a law firm, and we can’t represent you. Policies, laws and deadlines vary and change, so check your policy and talk with a licensed attorney in your state before relying on anything here.

Who This Is For

If you’re a driver wondering what an umpire costs you, see appraisal clause umpire cost.

How We Work as Umpire

  1. Both appraisers agree to use us, or we’re appointed as the policy allows.
  2. We confirm we have no conflict with either side.
  3. Each appraiser sends their appraisal and supporting documents.
  4. We review the vehicle, the comparable cars and the adjustments on both sides.
  5. We issue a written decision. Under most policies, a decision signed by the umpire and one appraiser sets the value.

What We Review

Neutral by Design

As umpire, we don’t take a side. We don’t act as umpire on a claim where we’ve appraised the vehicle for either party.

Licensing

We’re licensed in North Carolina and South Carolina and serve as umpire nationwide where those licenses are recognized or no license is required.

Fees and Booking

Call 910-333-6001 or email kevin@estimateconsultants.com for our current fee schedule and availability. Most work is done from photos, documents and records, so location is rarely a problem.

Common Questions

How is the umpire paid?

Usually split equally between the two sides, as most policies provide. Call for our current fee.

Can you be umpire if you appraised the car for one side?

No. We only serve as umpire on claims where we have no prior role.

How long does an umpire decision take?

It depends on how quickly both appraisals and documents arrive. Most decisions follow soon after.

Do you inspect the vehicle?

Most umpire decisions are made from photos, appraisals and records. If more is needed, we’ll ask.

Related Guides

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.