Appraisals
Diminished Value Total Loss Classic, Exotic & Collector Motorcycles Heavy Equipment RVs & Campers Estate & Probate Bank & Collateral IRS Vehicle Donation Divorce & Settlement State Guides & ResourcesMore
How It Works Total Loss Offer Check Total Loss Report Review Valuation Report ($99) Body Shops Meet Your Appraiser Call 910-333-6001A neutral umpire when the two appraisers can’t agree on a vehicle’s value.
By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026
When the appraisers on an auto appraisal clause can’t agree, the policy calls for an umpire. We serve as a neutral umpire on total loss and vehicle value disputes for appraisers, insurers and policyholders.
If you’re a driver wondering what an umpire costs you, see appraisal clause umpire cost.
As umpire, we don’t take a side. We don’t act as umpire on a claim where we’ve appraised the vehicle for either party.
We’re licensed in North Carolina and South Carolina and serve as umpire nationwide where those licenses are recognized or no license is required.
Call 910-333-6001 or email kevin@estimateconsultants.com for our current fee schedule and availability. Most work is done from photos, documents and records, so location is rarely a problem.
Usually split equally between the two sides, as most policies provide. Call for our current fee.
No. We only serve as umpire on claims where we have no prior role.
It depends on how quickly both appraisals and documents arrive. Most decisions follow soon after.
Most umpire decisions are made from photos, appraisals and records. If more is needed, we’ll ask.
Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.