Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

Is My Car Insurance Settlement Fair?

Most people have never had to judge an insurance offer before. Here’s a simple way to check it, whether your car was totaled or repaired.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Quick Answer

A fair settlement puts you back where you were before the accident. For a totaled car, that means enough to buy a similar car nearby, plus tax and fees where your state requires them. For a repaired car, it means a full, proper repair, and if the other driver was at fault, payment for the value your car lost because of the accident (diminished value), plus rental and towing.

Check your insurer’s valuation report

Upload your CCC, Mitchell or Audatex report to our free Insurance Total Loss Report Review. It finds the problems in the report and compares their value with matching vehicles near you.

Need it in writing? Our $99 Valuation Report gives your exact value, shown before you pay, with the comparable vehicles behind it. It’s prepared the same way as our certified appraisals, without the certification.

Check my report
Every claim is different. What applies to you depends on your policy, your state, your insurer and the facts of your accident. This page is general, educational information, not legal advice. Your insurer decides coverage under your policy, so read your policy and ask your insurer, and if you need advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney in your state.

If Your Car Was Totaled

What to do if the offer is low →

If Your Car Was Repaired

Do cars lose value after an accident? →

Get a Second Opinion

An independent appraiser works for you, not the insurance company. A free offer check or estimate can tell you quickly whether it’s worth pursuing.

Our total loss appraisal starts at $299, done online. Not sure yet? Check your insurance report free →

Our self-service diminished value package is $299. With full service ($299 + $199), we contact the insurer and support our valuation. Estimate your car’s diminished value for free →

In North Carolina or South Carolina? See total loss appraisals in North Carolina and in South Carolina.

Common Questions

How do I know if a total loss offer is fair?

See whether you could buy a similar car nearby for that amount, and check the valuation report for errors in trim, mileage, options and condition.

What should a car accident settlement include?

Repairs or the car’s value, towing, storage, rental or loss of use, and, when the other driver was at fault, diminished value. What applies depends on your situation and state.

Can I get paid for my car losing value after it was fixed?

Often, if the other driver was at fault. That’s a diminished value claim with their insurance.

Who can tell me if my settlement is fair?

An independent appraiser can review the numbers. For questions about your rights, talk with an attorney in your state.

Related Guides

Get Started: Total Loss Appraisal (from $299)

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.