Appraisals
Diminished Value Total Loss Classic, Exotic & Collector Motorcycles Heavy Equipment RVs & Campers Estate & Probate Bank & Collateral IRS Vehicle Donation Divorce & Settlement State Guides & ResourcesMore
How It Works Total Loss Offer Check Total Loss Report Review Valuation Report ($99) Body Shops Meet Your Appraiser Call 910-333-6001Short answers on car insurance claims you can use as written, with attribution.
By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026
Kevin Murty is an independent vehicle appraiser and owner of Estimate Consultants. He holds motor vehicle damage appraiser licenses in North Carolina and South Carolina and is ASCAA certified. He appraises diminished value, total loss and appraisal clause disputes for drivers nationwide.
The quotes below can be used as written, with attribution. For an interview or a quote on something else, call or text 910-333-6001 or email kevin@estimateconsultants.com.
Press coverage · State-by-state data · Embed our state rules map
What is diminished value?
“A car that has been in an accident is usually worth less than the same car without one, even after a good repair. That difference is diminished value, and in most states the at-fault driver’s insurer owes it.”
Why don’t more people claim it?
“Most people don’t know it exists. Insurers rarely bring it up, and it’s easy to sign a release that ends the claim before anyone mentions it.”
What do insurers usually offer?
“Many start with a formula that caps the amount and cuts it further for mileage and damage. The result often has little to do with what buyers will actually pay for the car.”
What should a driver do first?
“Keep the repair invoice and photos, and don’t sign a full property damage release until the diminished value part is settled.”
Attribute quotes to: Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser, Estimate Consultants.
Is the first total loss offer final?
“No. It’s the insurer’s number, not the last word. Ask for the valuation report and check the comparable cars it used.”
What do people miss in total loss reports?
“Comparable cars with a lower trim, higher mileage or a different region, and condition deductions nobody explained. Sales tax and fees are also left out more often than people expect.”
What is the appraisal clause?
“Most auto policies have one. If you and your insurer disagree on the value, each side hires an appraiser, and an umpire settles it if they can’t agree.”
Attribute quotes to: Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser, Estimate Consultants.
Does uninsured motorist coverage fix my car?
“It depends on the state. In 26 states, uninsured motorist coverage pays for injuries only, so the car isn’t covered unless you have collision coverage.”
How long do drivers have to claim car damage?
“It ranges from 2 years in 16 states to 10 years in Rhode Island. Many people wait too long because they’re still dealing with the repair.”
When is a car totaled?
“There’s no national rule. 22 states leave it to the insurer, 18 use 75% of the car’s value, and a few wait until repairs cost the full value.”
Attribute quotes to: Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser, Estimate Consultants.
Do hail and flood claims work differently?
“They’re usually claims on your own policy under comprehensive coverage, so there’s no at-fault driver and no diminished value claim. The appraisal clause can still apply if the car is totaled.”
What should drivers do after a storm?
“Take photos before anything is moved or cleaned, and report it quickly. After a big storm, insurers get backed up, so it helps to be early in line.”
Attribute quotes to: Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser, Estimate Consultants.
Yes. Use them as written and attribute them to Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser, Estimate Consultants.
Call or text 910-333-6001 or email kevin@estimateconsultants.com.
From the state-by-state tables on our site, which cite each state’s law. The full map is at estimateconsultants.com/car-claim-rules-by-state-map.html.
Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.