Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

Other Driver’s Insurance Won’t Pay Enough?

When someone else causes the accident, you expect their insurance to make it right. When the offer falls short, here’s what you can do.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Quick Answer

You have a few options. Push back with your own evidence (estimates, comparable listings, an independent appraisal). Use your own policy instead, if you have collision coverage, and let your insurer collect from theirs. And if your car was repaired, ask about diminished value, the value your car lost because of the accident, which the at-fault insurer usually owes on top of repairs.

Every claim is different. What applies to you depends on your policy, your state, your insurer and the facts of your accident. This page is general, educational information, not legal advice. Your insurer decides coverage under your policy, so read your policy and ask your insurer, and if you need advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney in your state.

Common Shortfalls

Your Options

How We Help

We value the loss independently and give you a report you can send to the insurer. With full service, we contact the insurer for you.

Our self-service diminished value package is $299. With full service ($299 + $199), we contact the insurer and support our valuation. Estimate your car’s diminished value for free →

Common Questions

What can I do if the at-fault insurance offer is too low?

Send evidence like estimates and an independent appraisal, use your own collision coverage, and ask about diminished value.

Does the other driver’s insurance have to pay for diminished value?

In most states the at-fault driver is responsible for the value your car lost, and their insurer handles that claim. Michigan’s no-fault system works differently.

Should I use my own insurance instead?

It’s often faster if you have collision coverage. You may pay your deductible first, then get it back if your insurer recovers from the other side.

How long do I have?

It depends on the state, usually 2 to 6 years for vehicle damage. Don’t wait until the end.

Related Guides

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.