Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

How Much Does an Appraisal Clause Umpire Cost?

The umpire is the part of the appraisal clause people worry about most. Here’s what an umpire does, who pays, and what it usually costs you.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Short Answer

Under typical policy wording, you and the insurance company split the umpire’s fee equally. In our experience, a share usually runs roughly $200 to $300. When we’re your appraiser, our fee already includes your share of the umpire’s fee. And most cases never need an umpire at all.

What an Umpire Does

In the appraisal clause, each side has its own appraiser. The two appraisers try to agree on your car’s value. Only if they can’t agree does the umpire come in.

The umpire reviews both appraisals and the supporting comparable vehicles, then decides. Under typical policy wording, an agreement by any two of the three (the umpire and one appraiser) sets the value.

Who Pays for What

Check your own policy’s appraisal section, since wording varies.

How the Umpire Is Chosen

Usually the two appraisers agree on an umpire together. Some policies say a court can pick one if the appraisers can’t agree on who it should be, but that’s rare.

Is It Worth the Risk?

Compare the possible umpire share to the gap between the insurer’s offer and what your car is really worth. If the gap is a few thousand dollars, a few hundred for an umpire, if one is even needed, is usually a small piece of it.

Check your insurance report free → How the appraisal clause works, step by step →

Appraisers and insurers looking for a neutral umpire: see our umpire services.

In North Carolina or South Carolina? See total loss appraisals in North Carolina and in South Carolina.

Common Questions

How often is an umpire needed?

Not often. Most cases settle between the two appraisers once both sides have documented the car’s value.

Can the umpire side with the insurance company?

Yes. The umpire reviews both sides and decides. That’s why a well-documented appraisal with real comparable vehicles matters.

Do I pay the umpire up front?

It depends on the umpire. Some bill each side for its share once the decision is made. When we’re your appraiser, your share is already included in our fee.

Sources

This page is general information, not legal advice. We are not a law firm. Laws, deadlines and insurance policies vary by state and change over time. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney in your state.

Get Started: Total Loss Appraisal (from $299)

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.