Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

How Much Does an Accident Devalue a Car?

What our recent appraisals show about how much value a car loses after an accident, even with a good repair.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Quick Answer

A car with an accident on its history is usually worth noticeably less, even after a good repair. In our 7 most recent completed diminished value appraisals (October–November 2026), repaired cars lost 10.7% to 23.4% of their pre-accident value. The average loss was 16.5% (median 17.8%), and the median dollar loss was about $7,500. All 7 came in above the 10% cap used by the “17c” formula. These are appraised values, not amounts recovered from insurers.

Key Findings

The 7 Appraisals and Averages

VehicleRepair billFrame repairPre-accident valueValue lostDiminished value
2023 Kia electric crossover$5,125No$29,02910.73%$3,114
2025 Lexus three-row SUV$17,973Yes$58,78812.75%$7,493
2023 Tesla electric sedan$2,977No$28,88714.06%$4,061
2025 BMW luxury performance coupe$4,893No$75,43217.75%$13,389
2022 Chevrolet full-size pickup$6,543No$36,36818.38%$7,285
2026 RAM full-size pickup$4,332No$50,74818.54%$9,406
2021 Toyota midsize pickup$11,400Yes$34,82923.44%$8,165
Average (7 vehicles)$7,6062 of 7$44,86916.5%$7,559
Median$5,125 $36,36817.8%$7,493

These are appraised values from our reports, not amounts recovered from insurance companies. Dollar amounts are rounded to the nearest dollar.

How We Measured It

Each appraisal measures the same thing: how much less the market will pay for this exact car now that it has an accident on its record.

  1. Pre-accident trade-in value: the average of J.D. Power (NADA) and Kelley Blue Book values for the car’s year, trim, options and mileage.
  2. Post-accident trade-in offers: real offers on the car’s actual VIN after repair, from three buyers (for example Carvana, CarMax, DriveTime or local dealers). These buyers see the accident history.
  3. Percentage lost: the drop from step 1 to the average of step 2.
  4. Fair market value: the average of three comparable retail listings with no accident history, adjusted for mileage using the J.D. Power mileage table.
  5. Diminished value: the percentage lost applied to the fair market value, plus any documented adjustments.

All 7 were 2021–2026 vehicles with clean titles, and each had only the one accident on its history.

Limits of This Data

These figures are the diminished value we appraised, not what insurance companies paid. Settlements can be higher or lower than the appraised amount. This is also a small sample from one appraisal firm, not a national study. The cars were mostly newer and higher-value, which tends to raise the dollar loss. Every car, repair and market is different, so your number could be higher or lower. These figures are for general information only. They are not a prediction of your claim, and they are not legal advice. Insurance policies and state rules vary.

We’ll update this page as we complete more appraisals.

Using These Numbers

You’re welcome to quote these figures with a link to this page. Suggested citation:

Estimate Consultants, “How Much Does an Accident Devalue a Car? Our Appraisal Data” (November 2026), https://www.estimateconsultants.com/diminished-value-statistics.html

Related: The 17c formula · Do cars lose value after an accident? · Claim deadlines by state · Diminished value appraisals

For published research on how much value cars lose, see do cars lose value after an accident?.

In the Carolinas? See diminished value in North Carolina and in South Carolina.

Common Questions

How much value does a car lose after an accident?

In our 7 most recent completed diminished value appraisals, repaired cars lost 10.7% to 23.4% of their pre-accident value, 16.5% on average. The median appraised loss was about $7,500. These are appraised values, not amounts recovered from insurers, and every car and repair is different.

Is diminished value usually more than 10%?

In our recent appraisals, yes. All 7 came in above 10%, which is the starting cap in the 17c formula some insurers use to calculate diminished value offers.

Does a bigger repair bill mean more diminished value?

Not reliably. In our appraisals, diminished value ranged from about 0.4 to 2.7 times the repair bill. A $2,977 repair on an electric sedan still meant a 14% loss in value.

How do you calculate the percentage of value lost?

We compare the car’s pre-accident trade-in value (the average of J.D. Power and Kelley Blue Book) with real post-accident trade-in offers on the actual VIN, then apply that percentage to the car’s fair market value from clean-history comparable listings.

Sources

This page is general information, not legal advice. We are not a law firm. Laws, deadlines and insurance policies vary by state and change over time. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney in your state.

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.