Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

The 17c Formula: Why Your Diminished Value Offer Is So Low

If the insurance company offered you a few hundred dollars for your car’s lost value, there’s a good chance the adjuster used a formula called 17c. Here’s how it works, why it comes in low, and what you can do.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

What our appraisals show: in our 7 most recent diminished value appraisals, repaired cars lost 16.5% of their pre-accident value on average (range 10.7% to 23.4%), and every one was above the 10% cap in the 17c formula. These are appraised values, not amounts recovered. Diminished value statistics from our appraisals →

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Short Answer

Many insurers use the 17c formula, which caps the loss at 10% of the car’s value and then cuts it down again for damage and mileage. It came from a 2001 Georgia case, and Georgia has never adopted it as a required formula. You can dispute a 17c offer with an independent appraisal based on market data.

Where Did the 17c Formula Come From?

The formula comes from a Georgia case, State Farm v. Mabry. In 2001 the Georgia Supreme Court found State Farm had no proper method for figuring diminished value. State Farm adopted the “17(c)” method, named for the section of the case document it came from, and still uses it in Georgia under the court’s order.

Since then, many adjusters in other states have picked it up too. It isn’t a law anywhere. In 2008 Georgia’s insurance commissioner said the state has never endorsed any diminished value formula, and that insurers must consider all relevant information, including what the car owner provides.

How Does the 17c Formula Work?

  1. Start with the car’s value before the accident, usually from a pricing guide.
  2. Take 10% of that value. This is the most the formula will ever allow.
  3. Multiply by a damage number based on how bad the damage was.
  4. Multiply by a mileage number.

Damage multiplier

Severe structural damage1.00
Major structural and panel damage0.75
Moderate structural and panel damage0.50
Minor structural and panel damage0.25
No structural damage or replaced panels0.00

Mileage multiplier

0 – 19,9991.00
20,000 – 39,9990.80
40,000 – 59,9990.60
60,000 – 79,9990.40
80,000 – 99,9990.20
100,000 or more0.00

Example: a $30,000 car with minor damage and 45,000 miles. 10% of $30,000 is $3,000. Times 0.25 for minor damage is $750. Times 0.60 for mileage is $450.

Why Is the 17c Formula So Low?

Courts have noticed. In 2022 a federal appeals court reviewing a class action over 17c said the formula has “some fundamental flaws,” though it ruled each claim had to be judged on its own.

What to Do About a 17c Offer

  1. Don’t accept the first number. Ask the adjuster how they calculated it.
  2. Get an independent appraisal based on market data for your specific car: what it was worth before the accident and what it’s worth now with the accident on its record.
  3. Send the appraisal with a demand letter and ask the insurer to reconsider.
  4. Watch your deadline. Each state sets its own time limit. See our guides for North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, Tennessee, Georgia, Florida and Texas.

Our self-service package (from $299) gives you the appraisal, a demand letter template and instructions. With full service ($299 + $199), we contact the insurer and support our valuation. Estimate your car’s diminished value for free →

North Carolina Is Different: The Appraisal Option

In most states, if the at-fault driver’s insurance company won’t move off its 17c number, your choices are to keep negotiating or go to court. North Carolina gives you another option.

If you and the insurance company are more than $2,000 apart on your car’s loss in value (or 25% of its pre-accident value, if that’s less), state law lets either side demand an appraisal. Here’s how it works:

  1. Each side picks an appraiser. You choose yours; the insurance company chooses theirs.
  2. The two appraisers work out the loss in value using the car, the repairs and the market.
  3. If they can’t agree, an umpire decides. Umpires aren’t common, and if one is needed, our fee already includes your share.

That matters with 17c: instead of the insurance company’s formula setting the number, it’s decided by appraisers looking at your actual car. We serve as your appraiser in North Carolina’s process for $399 flat. North Carolina diminished value guide →

Source: N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-279.21(d1).

In the Carolinas? See diminished value in North Carolina and in South Carolina.

Common Questions

Is the 17c formula required by law?

No. It came out of a 2001 Georgia court case involving State Farm. Georgia’s insurance commissioner later said the state has never adopted or endorsed any diminished value formula, and that insurers must consider all relevant information, including what the car owner provides.

Do all insurance companies use 17c?

Not all, but many adjusters use it or a version of it. If your offer is a small round-looking number, ask the adjuster how it was calculated.

Can I dispute a 17c offer?

Yes. An offer is a starting point. Send the insurer an independent appraisal based on market data for your car, along with a demand letter. In North Carolina you may also be able to use the state’s diminished value appraisal process.

Why does 17c give zero for cars over 100,000 miles?

The formula’s mileage table drops to zero at 100,000 miles. Real buyers still pay less for a high-mileage car with an accident on its record, so the loss doesn’t simply disappear, though it is usually smaller.

Sources

This page is general information, not legal advice. We are not a law firm. Laws, deadlines and insurance policies vary by state and change over time. For advice about your situation, talk with a licensed attorney in your state.

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.