Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

How to Choose a Diminished Value Appraiser

Not every diminished value appraisal holds up when an adjuster pushes back. Here’s how to tell a solid appraiser from one that will cost you time.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Quick Answer

Choose an appraiser who measures your car’s loss with real market data (real offers on your car and comparable sales), not a formula; charges a flat fee, not a cut of your claim; is certified and, where your state requires it, licensed; and will stand behind the report if the insurer disputes it. Be wary of anyone who guarantees a dollar amount before seeing your car.

Every claim is different. This page is general, educational information, not legal advice. We’re vehicle appraisers, not a law firm, and we can’t represent you. Policies, laws and deadlines vary and change, so check your policy and talk with a licensed attorney in your state before relying on anything here.

8 Questions to Ask Before You Hire

  1. How do you measure the loss? Look for real buyer offers on your car’s VIN and comparable listings, not just a percentage off book value.
  2. Do you use the 17c formula? If the answer is yes, the report may come out close to the insurer’s own low number. See the 17c formula.
  3. What’s the fee, and is it flat? A percentage of your recovery gives the appraiser a reason to inflate the number, and adjusters know it.
  4. Are you certified, and licensed where it’s required? Some states license vehicle damage appraisers. Ask which states the appraiser is licensed in.
  5. Can I see what a report includes? Ask for a list of the sections, even if they can’t share another client’s report.
  6. What happens if the insurer disputes it? Will they answer the adjuster’s questions, write a rebuttal, or testify if it goes to court?
  7. How long does it take? A few business days after you send photos and the repair bill is normal.
  8. Who does the work? You want the person who signs the report to be the one who did the analysis.

Red Flags

What a Good Report Includes

Our own results are on our diminished value statistics page.

Appraiser, Public Adjuster or Attorney?

An appraiser puts a number on the value your car lost. A public adjuster or attorney handles the claim itself, usually for a percentage. Many people only need the appraisal. See appraiser vs. public adjuster vs. attorney.

How We Help

For reference, here’s how we answer those questions: we use real offers on your VIN and comparable sales, our fees are flat, we’re ASCAA certified and licensed in North Carolina and South Carolina, and our full-service option includes talking with the insurer about our valuation.

We appraise your vehicle independently and online, from photos, and give you a report you can send to the insurer, use in an appraisal clause, or bring to court. Call or text 910-333-6001 to get started.

Diminished value claims aren’t offered in Nebraska or Michigan.

Common Questions

What should I look for in a diminished value appraiser?

Market-based methods, a flat fee, certification and any license your state requires, a detailed written report, and support if the insurer disputes it.

Should a diminished value appraiser charge a percentage?

A flat fee is better. A percentage of your recovery gives the appraiser a reason to inflate the number, and insurers discount those reports.

Does the appraiser need to be licensed?

Some states license vehicle damage appraisers. Ask which states the appraiser is licensed in and whether your state requires it.

How much does a diminished value appraisal cost?

Ours start at $299. See our cost guide for what affects the price.

Related Guides

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.