Estimate Consultants Logo
Estimate Consultants Independent Automotive Appraisals

Diminished Value & Total Loss Claims by Insurance Company

Diminished value and total loss steps that work with any insurer, plus notes for 31 companies.

As seen on ABC, Fox News, NBC, AP, Sports Illustrated, International Business Times, Morning News and CBS

By Kevin Murty, ASCAA certified vehicle appraiser · Updated November 2026

Quick Answer

It depends on whose insurer it is. If the other driver’s insurer hit you, you can usually claim your car’s diminished value (its lost resale value) from that insurer as a third-party claim. If your own insurer totaled your car, check your policy for an appraisal clause, which lets you dispute a low offer with your own appraiser. The steps are the same for every company; notes for specific insurers are below.

Every claim is different. This page is general, educational information, not legal advice. We’re vehicle appraisers, not a law firm, and we can’t represent you. Policies, laws and deadlines vary and change, so check your policy and talk with a licensed attorney in your state before relying on anything here.

Find Your Insurance Company

Diminished Value When the Other Driver’s Insurer Is Paying

  1. Open a property damage claim with the at-fault driver’s insurer and tell the adjuster in writing that you’re also claiming diminished value.
  2. Ask how they calculate it. Many insurers use a formula such as 17c that caps the amount. Ask for their number in writing.
  3. Send an independent appraisal with your repair invoice and photos. A report based on market data carries more weight than an opinion.
  4. Don’t sign a release that covers all property damage until diminished value is settled.
  5. If you’re still far apart: North Carolina has an appraisal option for diminished value against the at-fault insurer, South Carolina has property damage arbitration, and small claims court is available in most states. what to do when the offer is too low, by state

A Low Total Loss Offer From Your Insurer

  1. Ask for the valuation report, including the comparable vehicles, and check that they match your car’s trim, options and mileage. How to read a CCC report · a Mitchell report Check it with our free total loss report review.
  2. Check the extras: most total loss payments should include sales tax and fees where your state requires it, and subtract your deductible on your own policy.
  3. Look for “Appraisal” in the physical damage part of your policy. Most auto policies have one, but wording varies.
  4. Invoking it: notify the insurer in writing, each side names an appraiser, and an umpire decides if the two can’t agree. Umpires aren’t common, and if one is needed, our fee already includes your share.
  5. Worth it? A gap of about $1,200 or more between the offer and your car’s value is usually worth disputing. How to invoke the appraisal clause

What total loss percentage does my insurance company use?

Insurance companies don’t have one company-wide percentage. State Farm, GEICO, Progressive, Allstate, American Family and the others all follow the state’s total loss threshold where the state sets one, such as 75% of the car’s value in North Carolina and South Carolina. In states with no fixed percentage, each company uses its own formula, usually comparing the repair estimate plus the salvage value with what the car was worth. So the same damage can total a car in one state and not in the next. See the total loss threshold in every state.

Notes by Insurance Company

Alfa

The steps above apply to Alfa claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Allstate

American Family

The steps above apply to American Family claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Amica

The steps above apply to Amica claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Auto-Owners

The steps above apply to Auto-Owners claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Bristol West

Bristol West and Farmers

Bristol West is part of Farmers. Many Bristol West policies carry lower limits.

Some policies carry only the minimum property damage coverage your state requires. If your repair, diminished value and other losses add up to more than the at-fault driver’s limit, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on your state and policy.

The other driver’s insurance won’t pay enough →

Country Financial

The steps above apply to Country Financial claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Dairyland

Dairyland and Sentry

Dairyland is part of Sentry Insurance.

Some policies carry only the minimum property damage coverage your state requires. If your repair, diminished value and other losses add up to more than the at-fault driver’s limit, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on your state and policy.

The other driver’s insurance won’t pay enough →

Direct Auto

Direct Auto and National General

Direct Auto is part of National General, which is owned by Allstate. Many Direct Auto policies carry lower limits.

Some policies carry only the minimum property damage coverage your state requires. If your repair, diminished value and other losses add up to more than the at-fault driver’s limit, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on your state and policy.

The other driver’s insurance won’t pay enough →

Erie

The steps above apply to Erie claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Farm Bureau

Each State Has Its Own Farm Bureau

Farm Bureau insurance is sold by separate companies in each state, such as North Carolina Farm Bureau and South Carolina Farm Bureau. Policy wording and claim handling vary by company, so read the policy from your state’s Farm Bureau and use the contact on your claim paperwork.

GEICO

Claims: geico.com/claims.

If the car is drivable, GEICO usually schedules a drive-in inspection; if it isn’t, it sends an adjuster to the car.

You can use any repair shop. Repairs through GEICO’s Auto Repair Xpress program come with a written guarantee for as long as you own the car.

En español

Infinity

Infinity and Kemper

Infinity is part of Kemper. Many Infinity policies carry lower limits.

Some policies carry only the minimum property damage coverage your state requires. If your repair, diminished value and other losses add up to more than the at-fault driver’s limit, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on your state and policy.

The other driver’s insurance won’t pay enough →

Kemper

If the Other Driver Has a Low-Limit Policy

Some policies carry only the minimum property damage coverage your state requires. If your repair, diminished value and other losses add up to more than the at-fault driver’s limit, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on your state and policy.

The other driver’s insurance won’t pay enough →

Liberty Mutual

If a Liberty Mutual customer hit you, file at Liberty Mutual’s third-party claims page or call 800-2CLAIMS. You’ll need the claim number to track it online.

Safeco Policies

Safeco is part of Liberty Mutual. If your policy or the other driver’s policy is with Safeco, the same steps apply.

Mercury

The steps above apply to Mercury claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

National General

Who Is National General?

National General is part of Allstate. Some National General policies are written through companies with other names, such as Integon, so the name on the paperwork may not match the brand you know. The steps on this page are the same either way.

En español

Nationwide

Claims: nationwide.com auto claims or 1-800-421-3535. Nationwide can also send claim updates by text.

Penn National

The steps above apply to Penn National claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Progressive

Claims: progressive.com/claims. Total loss details: Progressive total loss FAQ.

Progressive inspects the car before deciding it’s a total loss, then values it against comparable vehicles with help from a third-party valuation company.

Policyholders with rental coverage keep the rental for up to three days after Progressive gives its value, so review the valuation quickly.

You can keep the totaled car, or sign the title over to Progressive after the claim is paid.

En español

Root

App-Based Claims

Root handles claims mostly through its app. Keep copies of everything you upload and send your diminished value demand and appraisal in a form you can save, with the date.

Safeco

Safeco and Liberty Mutual

Safeco is part of Liberty Mutual. Safeco policies are usually sold through independent agents, but claims decisions are made by the adjuster, so send your demand to the adjuster in writing.

Sentry

The steps above apply to Sentry claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

Shelter

The steps above apply to Shelter claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

State Farm

Claims: statefarm.com/claims/auto.

State Farm and Diminished Value in Court

Two well-known diminished value cases involved State Farm policies:

  • Georgia: the Georgia Supreme Court held that insurers must consider diminished value on physical damage claims under the policyholder’s own policy (State Farm v. Mabry, 2001).
  • South Carolina: the S.C. Supreme Court held that a policy paying the lesser of repair cost or actual cash value doesn’t also owe diminished value on the policyholder’s own collision claim (Schulmeyer v. State Farm, 2003).

Neither case changes a third-party claim: if a State Farm driver hit you, you can claim diminished value from State Farm in both states.

En español

The General

The General and American Family

The General is part of American Family. Many policies from The General carry lower limits.

Some policies carry only the minimum property damage coverage your state requires. If your repair, diminished value and other losses add up to more than the at-fault driver’s limit, your own uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage may help, depending on your state and policy.

The other driver’s insurance won’t pay enough →

The Hanover

The steps above apply to The Hanover claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

The Hartford

AARP Auto Insurance

The Hartford writes the AARP auto insurance program. If your policy or the other driver’s is “AARP Auto Insurance from The Hartford,” the same steps apply.

Travelers

The steps above apply to Travelers claims. Ask the adjuster for everything in writing, including the valuation report on a total loss.

USAA

If a USAA member hit you, file at USAA’s third-party claims page, available around the clock.

USAA says reviewing a repair estimate can take up to 7 business days, and repairs start after the adjuster approves the estimate.

If USAA accepts responsibility, it reimburses a rental when your car isn’t drivable or once repairs start.

Military Families and Moves

USAA members often move between states. Which state’s rules apply can depend on where the accident happened and where your policy was written, so check deadlines early and ask an attorney if you’ve moved. Because we appraise from photos, we can work with you wherever you’re stationed now.

Diminished value deadlines by state →

We’re not affiliated with any insurer listed; names are used only to identify them. Claims links go to each company’s own website.

How We Help

We appraise your vehicle independently and online, from photos, and give you a report you can send to the insurer, use in an appraisal clause, or bring to court. Call or text 910-333-6001 to get started.

Diminished value claims aren’t offered in Nebraska or Michigan.

Common Questions

Does my insurance company have to pay diminished value?

If the other driver caused the accident, their insurer usually owes it in most states. Your own policy usually doesn’t cover it.

Can I dispute a total loss offer from my own insurer?

Yes. Ask for the valuation report, point out errors, and use the appraisal clause in most policies if you still disagree.

Does it matter which insurance company it is?

The steps are the same. Each company has its own claims process and forms, noted above where we have them.

Related Guides

Get Started

Call 910-333-6001

Can’t call right now? You can also start in the appraisal portal, text us or email us.